#1. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY Stony Brook Eastern Long Island Hospital, NY 5 miles Overall hospital rating: 3.0
#2. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY Peconic Bay Medical Center, NY 21 miles Overall hospital rating: 3.0
#3. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY Lawrence & Memorial Hospital, CT 22 miles Overall hospital rating: 3.0
#6. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY William W Backus Hospital, CT 36 miles Overall hospital rating: 4.0
#7. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY Yale-New Haven Hospital, CT 37 miles Overall hospital rating: 3.0
#12. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY Masonicare Health Center Hospital, CT 40 miles Overall hospital rating: 4.0
#13. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY John T Mather Memorial Hospital of Port Jefferson, NY 40 miles Overall hospital rating: 2.0
#14. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY Long Island Community Hospital, NY 40 miles Overall hospital rating: 1.0
#16. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY Midstate Medical Center, CT 43 miles Overall hospital rating: 4.0
#17. Hospitals near Shelter Island, NY Suny/Stony Brook University Hospital, NY 44 miles Overall hospital rating: 4.0